Should You Sell or Renovate?

Are you contemplating whether to sell your property or upgrade it?

When factoring in all of the expenditures of moving, some folks decide that it may be easier to renovate their existing home rather than starting the search for a new one.

Starter homes were never meant for long-term living, but rather than relocating some families have decided to add on to their formerly cramped homes with additions, or even starting from scratch on the same plot of land. These options for upgrading are not without their flaws, and before starting a costly renovation it’s important to look at the pros and cons of relocating and renovating.

Buying a Home.
Buying a new home isn’t always cut and dry. If you can expect to sell your current home for $400,000 dollars to upgrade to a $700,000 home, the upgrade fee will be more than an easy $300,000.

You will need to factor in the percentage that is paid out to the realtors as well as the land transfer fees. After everything you will have legal fees that need to be paid out and the small expenditures along the way like repairs to your existing home and staging fees. Your cost to upgrade can climb almost $50,000 based on what city you live in.

Building from Scratch.
Demolishing your current home and building something that is customized to your tastes and needs is an attractive idea. But remember, you’ll be relying on builders and contractors to stay on track and in the mean time you’ll need to find a place to live and store your furniture.

A quality contractor can build a house with all of the amenities for approximately $300 per square foot for a 2400 square foot home. But again you’ll need to factor in architectural fees, landscaping, hydro, plumbing, labour, and materials. Going for high-end finishings can add a whopping price tag to your end game and end up costing almost $790,000.

Building an Addition.

Building an addition has some of the same positives as building from scratch, but again many of the same negative factors, like finding alternative living arrangements and dealing with contractors. You could do an addition that would double your floor space for half the price of building from scratch.


Final Decision.

In the end, packing up your things and moving to a new house is the least expensive option, and building from scratch is the most expensive. Working with the right team of realtors, you can find the right home for your family needs within your budget and price range. However, don’t let this turn you off renovating. The right upgrades can add tons of value to your next home.


Share this post on

pumpkins
By Hudson Smith • September 21, 2026
There’s something about fall in Guelph that makes you want to grab a sweater, order something pumpkin-spiced, and spend an afternoon at a local farm. Whether you’re searching for the perfect pumpkin to carve, planning a family day out, or just looking for a great fall photo spot, there are plenty of pumpkin patches and farms in and around Guelph worth visiting.  Here are some of our favourite spots to add to your fall bucket list.
Apple Picking
By Hudson Smith • September 18, 2026
There’s something about apple-picking season that makes it officially feel like fall in Guelph. Crisp mornings, country roads, fresh apples, warm baked goods and a day spent outside are all part of the experience.
By Hudson Smith • September 16, 2026
Over the past several years, a steady stream of people have made the move west from the Greater Toronto Area to Guelph, and once you spend a little time in the city, it is easy to understand why. Guelph offers something that has become increasingly rare in Southwestern Ontario, a genuine sense of community and space without cutting yourself off from the opportunities the GTA provides. The Commute Is More Manageable Than People Expect The GO Train connects Guelph Central Station directly to Toronto's Union Station, with the trip taking roughly ninety minutes. For anyone who has spent time commuting within the GTA itself, that number often sounds more reasonable than expected, especially once you factor in that Guelph commuters are trading traffic and crowded platforms for a calmer, more predictable ride. For people who only need to be in the office a few days a week, the trade off tends to make even more sense. More Space for the Same Budget One of the most common reasons people give for looking outside Toronto is simple. Housing dollars stretch further in Guelph. Detached homes, larger lots, and neighbourhoods with room to grow are still attainable here in a way that has become increasingly difficult to find closer to the downtown core of the GTA. For young families especially, that difference can mean the gap between renting indefinitely and actually settling into a home that fits their long term plans. A Slower Pace Without Losing the Amenities What sets Guelph apart from a lot of smaller commuter towns is that it does not feel like you are sacrificing much to get that extra space and breathing room. The city has a full hospital, a major university, a strong restaurant and brewery scene, and enough cultural programming through venues like the River Run Centre to keep things interesting year round. It is a rare combination, small city calm paired with genuine city amenities. A Growing, Diverse Community Guelph has also become notably more diverse over the past decade, partly thanks to the university drawing people from across the country and around the world, and partly because more families are choosing to relocate here from bigger cities. That shift has added new energy to the local food scene, the festival calendar, and the overall character of the city, while still keeping the strong sense of community that longtime residents value most. Not Just a Bedroom Community It is worth noting that Guelph is not simply a place people sleep before commuting elsewhere. Major employers like the University of Guelph, Linamar, and Sleeman Brewery mean a significant portion of residents work locally, which helps the city maintain its own identity rather than functioning purely as a Toronto suburb. That local employment base is part of why Guelph's downtown and neighbourhood business districts have stayed as vibrant as they have. Weighing the Move For anyone currently living in the GTA and wondering whether a move to Guelph makes sense, the honest answer usually comes down to priorities. For people who want more space, a stronger sense of community, and a commute that is still workable a few days a week, Guelph consistently comes up as one of the more compelling options in the region. The best way to know for sure is to actually spend time here, walk a few neighbourhoods, sit at the farmers market on a Saturday morning, and get a feel for the pace of life before making any decisions. Guelph has a way of making its case simply by being itself, and for a growing number of former Torontonians, that has been more than enough.
See More Posts